Mulan (2009) [Film Review]

Mulan; or, Rise of a Legend
     Someone once said, go too far from home and you will lose your roots. Kill too many people, and you will forget yourself. If you die in battle, your life will sink into the ground like rain and vanish without a trace. If at that time, you fall in love with someone, hope will blossom again from the earth and embrace life passionately.
Hua Mulan, the courageous woman who joined the ranks of the Imperial Army and saved China from invasion, needs no introduction. The ancient Chinese legend was popularised in the West by the 1998 Disney animation under the same title. In the view of the approaching live-action adaptation (to be premiered on September 4, 2020 on Disney+), I think it is worth to take a look at other popular retelling of Mulan’s story, namely Jingle Ma’s production from the year 2009 with Vicky Zhao in the leading role.
Release Info
Directed by: Jingle Ma Staring: Vicky Zhao, Chen Kun, Hu Jun, Jaycee Chan, Yu Rongguang
Language: Mandarin Original Title: 花木蘭 Runtime: 114 min

Synopsis
China, 450 A.D. The kingdom is under attack from the Rouran tribes. Due to the announcement of a nationwide draft, a retired soldier Hua Hu (Yu Rongguang) is enlisted again. However, he is elderly man struggling with disability. His only daughter Hua Mulan (Vicky Zhao) cannot accept this and she disguises herself as a man, takes her father’s weapon and escapes the household. She joins the army and participates in the confrontations with the Rourans. Her achievements on the battlefield are so outstanding that Mulan even receives the title of the general. However, in the course of the twelve year war, Mulan cannot stand losing her friends in battles. She mourns the love of her life, Wentai (Chen Kun).
Fight Like a Butterfly
Having seen this movie and the 1998 animation back to back, I noticed that people at Disney have taken a lot of liberties with the original story. Jingle Ma’s movie is an attempt to faithfully represent the source of material. In Mulan (2009) there is no place for magic (sorry, Mushu!) and saving the Emperor subplot does not occur at all. Interestingly, two people know Mulan’s secret and they do not give it away. What is more, she becomes a badass general and fights for twelve years (while accepting no reward for her sacrifices)! The legend of Mulan is about the devotion of a single woman to her kingdom.
The movie follows the pattern of a straightforward historical epic. Introduction is very short and we quickly shift to Mulan as an imperial soldier. There are lots of (and lots) of battle scenes in the film which, to me, are either a hit or miss. If you like watching confrontations between two armies taken straight as if from Shogun: Total War game, then you will enjoy the film.
That being said, I appreciate Mulan (2009) for trying to adapt the legend as faithfully as possible. After watching the animation numerous times in my childhood, this live-action endeavour provides a breath of fresh air in terms of storyline. In contrast, the trailer footage from the upcoming Disney movie leaves me a bit unsatisfied. I am genuinely worried that the 2020 production will suffer from bland script and over-the-top CGI sequences.
With regard to performances, Vicky Zhao totally nails it as Mulan. Seeing her in a military armour, I thought to myself: “Yeah, she can totally pass as a guy in that.” Whereas outside of the outfit, she was a delicate and graceful woman! It is no wonder that Vicky was chosen over such super stars as Michelle Yeoh and Zhang Ziyi. Second best performer is Chen Kun as Wentai. I really liked the love story between the characters which makes the ending all the more heartbreaking.
Recommendations
If you are waiting to check out the Disney's live-action version, try to watch this one as well. Mulan (2009) is a decent historical epic which will make you look at the character of Hua Mulan from a different perspective. I hope that I will also be able to check out the numerous drama adaptations of the legend which were made over the years.
Overall score: 8/10
«Enjoyed this post? Never miss out on future posts by following us»

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comment moderation is switched on due to recent spam postings.