True Bromance: Chivalry, Honour, and Violence in John Woo's Movies [Editorial]

Disclaimer: The following article contains spoilers for movies A Better Tomorrow (1986), A Better Tomorrow II (1987), The Killer (1989), Bullet in the Head (1990), and Hard Boiled (1992). Synopses for the films were reappropriated from my individual blog reviews. John Woo’s comedies from the 1970s and his Hollywood blockbusters do not constitute the analytical subject matter of the text.
 
     I wanted the mood to resemble a dream, like they have something to hope for. It’s a dream for the killer. No matter where I am, what I love to do is watch people’s faces. Even when walking on a street, I also love to watch different faces. I wonder about the feeling. It’s very interesting, you’re watching a different face and getting a different feeling. ~ John Woo
 
Enthusiasts of Asian Cinema often hail John Woo as the master of action movies packed with guns, explosions, and massive set pieces. The director in question, however, distances himself from this title. It goes without saying that his most popular Hong Kong productions from the 1980s and the 1990s constitute idiosyncratic viewing experiences, but what makes them so unique, especially to Western viewers? Let's explore this issue in the herein editorial.
     In order to gain greater understanding of John Woo's movies, we need to take a look at the life of the film auteur himself. Woo was born as Wu Yu-seng on the 1st of May, 1946 in Guangzhou, China. His father was a teacher and a literary scholar, while the mother did manual labour. Because of the ruthless rule of Mao Zedong after the war, the family had to flee to Hong Kong in order to avoid persecution for their Christian background. In a new land, they experienced a great deal of hardships as well: the father suffered from tuberculosis while 3-year-old Woo had to undergo a spine operation. It was not until five years later when he regained the ability to walk properly. It was in the childhood years when he had found consolation in religion and was planning to become a Christian minister.
John Woo giving instructions on the set of Hard Boiled.
     (Un)surprisingly, shy and reserved Woo decided to change his career choice when he discovered the magic of cinema. He felt deeply passionate about the French New Wave (the movies of Jean-Pierre Melville, in particular) and Westerns. The ending of Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid about two comrades trying to shoot their way through against all odds engraved itself deeply into the mind of a future filmmaker.
     Nevertheless, it was not like Woo entered the industry with immediate success. He had a steady work in the 1970s, directing standard kung fu flicks and comedies, but he felt increasingly displeased with these endeavours because of the lack of creative control. It was in the mid-1980s when a colleague and fellow collaborator, Tsui Hark provided Woo with a funding to realise his movie ideas.

     A Better Tomorrow is a film that turned Woo into a respected filmmaker and jettisoned its leading man, Chow Yun-fat, into stardom. This is the classic good guys vs. the bad guys story set within the context of Hong Kong triads. Nevertheless, if we look beyond gunfights, gangsters, and 80s aesthetics, we will see that A Better Tomorrow is about the restoration of the Confucian family structure.
     Sun Tse-Ho (Ti Lung) is a trusted triad member who deals with distributing counterfeit dollars. His loyal helper and best friend is Mark (Chow Yun-fat) who is a cool-hand shooter. On the other hand, there is Kit (Leslie Cheung), Ho’s younger brother who joined the police academy and intends to become an officer. Ho supports his brother’s career choice, but does not reveal to him his real line of business. Ho decides that he will make one more distributing deal in Taiwan and then leave the triad for good. He travels there with a new guy called Shing (Waise Lee); however, all hell breaks loose and Ho is betrayed. In order to allow Shing to escape he turns himself over to the Taiwanese police. Three years later, Ho gets out of prison and he is determined to start a new life. He comes back to Hong Kong only to find that Kit (now a police inspector) does not want to speak to him and that Mark is a crippled beggar. Shing became the new leader of the triad and he offers Ho reinstatement in the organisation. Ho refuses, yet he quickly realises that his brother is in danger.

     Essentially, Ho, the main protagonist of the story, restores his fraternal bond with Kit, who is at the opposite side of the law. Nevertheless, this process of restoration cannot be completed without a sacrifice. It is the character of Mark (a spiritual brother of Ho) who brings two estranged men together in the bombastic finale that takes away his life. Brothers united again take matters into their own hands and execute Shing, the ruthless villain. Still, Ho is aware that he has to pay the price for his actions, and thus allows himself to be arrested by Kit.
     John Woo manages to evoke the bromance relationship because he puts emphasis on honour and integrity of his male characters. Just as in Romance of the Three Kingdoms or Arthurian legends, men with a steadfast morality compass do whatever it takes to restore order. This is what matters the most, not even a love for a woman can overshadow this because the female figure always plays a secondary part in the storyline.

     We see the recurrence of this bromance pattern yet again in A Better Tomorrow II, but the configuration of characters is different this time. Sung Tse-Ho (Ti Lung) serves his time in prison after the events from the original film. The police offer him early parole in exchange for doing a spy job on Ho’s ex-mentor, Lung Sei (Dean Shek), who is suspected of counterfeiting. Ho agrees when his brother’s wife Jackie (Emily Chu) tells him that Kit (Leslie Cheung) is working on the case. Ho reunites with his brother and they decide to work together, but soon after, Lung is framed for murder and he flees to New York. Ho and Kit try to protect his daughter, but she is killed by the triads. Upon hearing devastating news, Lung loses his sanity. Meanwhile, it turns out that Mark had a twin brother called Ken... (Chow Yun-fat) who also happens to live in New York. After Ho’s phone call, Ken finds Lung and nurses him back to health while attempting to flee from assassins sent by the triads. Eventually, Ken, Lung, Ho and Kit reunite together in Hong Kong and they decide to take down the man who betrayed Lung and took over his organisation, Ko Ying-pui (Kwan Shan).
     Regardless of the sequel’s dubious quality (making things more explosive and coming with an outrageous excuse to bring back Chow Yun-fat), the story-arc of Ho is extremely tragic here. The man paid his dues from the first movie, and does not want to get involved in crime undertakings again, but he has to because his friend, Lung, was betrayed. On top of that, Kit, his dear brother, is brutally killed at the end of the second act. Kit’s wife serves no other purpose but to underline her husband’s chivalry in a scene where the two are talking over the phone.

     Kit’s death subsequently pushes Ho to go all out against the triads. In the film’s finale, we see the haunting image of Ho, Ken, and Lung alive but badly injured after storming the villain’s house and fighting masses of expandable baddies. The order has been restored but at what cost?
     After a disappointing reception of A Better Tomorrow II, Woo had a falling out with Hark who went to single-handedly make A Better Tomorrow III. Woo, on the other hand, went to shoot his dream project called The Killer, a tribute to the cinematic style of Jean-Pierre Melville and Martin Scorsese.

     Ah Jong (Chow Yun-fat) is an assassin for hire. His long-time friend, Fung (Chu Kong), frequently serves as the middleman when offers are being made. During one of the assignments, Jong accidentally damages the eyes of the singer, Jennie (Sally Yeh). Guilt-ridden Jong looks after Jennie and tries to gather money necessary for her surgery. After killing a high-profile mobster, Jong is betrayed by his employers who want him dead. To make matters worse, the police detective Li Ying (Danny Lee) is on his trail as well.
     In The Killer, Woo depicts three sets of male friendships: 1) between two killers (Jong and Fung); 2) between two cops (Li and Tsang) 3) between a killer and a cop (Jong and Li). Although the affair with Jenny is the plot device which drives the main protagonist in the story, the woman never takes a center stage. She represents a disruption of the order; therefore, Jong and Li unite in the film’s finale (almost like Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid) to restore the order. However, sacrifices have to be made.
     That is to say, for bromance to take place, the two characters have to lose their beloved friends. Sergeant Tsang dies in the line of duty while investigating Jong, while Fung gives up his life to get the money for Jong from the triads. The death of the latter character is especially emotional and it reminded me greatly about the relationship between knight Roland and his loyal paladin Olivier de Vienne as described in the 11th-century epic poem The Song of Roland. Evidently, Woo did not take inspiration from the poem, but he replicated the archetypes of chivalric heroes in action which are present in literary traditions of the Orient as well as the Occident.
     In the final confrontation, the bro power between Jong and Li is so much over 9000 that they manage to defeat a whole army of triad lowlifes on their own. Nevertheless, Jong loses his life in a stand-off against the villain. Similarly to Ho in A Better Tomorrow, Jong has to atone for his past sins, and he does so by saving Jennie in the church (Christian imagery is extremely prominent in The Killer). The last moment between Jong and Jennie, when the two can’t find each other because of their blindness, eerily references Greek tragedies like Oedipus Rex or Antigone. In the end, it is the cop who shoots the villain.
     In 1990, Woo turned his original idea for A Better Tomorrow III into a stand-alone feature called Bullet in the Head. The movie tells the story of three friends: Ben (Tony Leung Chiu-wai), Frank (Jacky Cheung), and Paul (Waise Lee), who regularly brawl with gang members in Hong Kong during the 1960s. Unfortunately, Frank accidentally kills one of the mobsters and the friends decide to flee Hong Kong. They go to Saigon, in order to work as smugglers in the ravaged by war Vietnam. However, things do not go as planned and the protagonists find themselves on the run, together with a hitman Luke (Simon Yam) and a nightclub singer Sally (Yolinda Yam), from the Vietcong soldiers. Eventually, Paul betrays his friends for a box of gold.
     Bullet in the Head stands out of John Woo’s rich repertoire as not being just a standard bullet-ballet flick. It is neither as fast paced as A Better Tomorrow nor as spectacular as Hard Boiled. Nevertheless, the film’s primary asset is a human drama set against the background of a harrowing military conflict. John Woo reinvents the “bromance formula” known from his other films by turning it into a war epic similar to Francis Ford Coppola’s Apocalypse Now.
     As in the previously discussed films, we have the theme of betrayal. Waise Lee again (as in A Better Tomorrow) plays a rotten individual who chooses wealth over his friends. What is more, he cripples Frank in a brutal manner, which pushes Ben to seek revenge. In addition, there is also a female character in-between the three men, but her subplot is more of a passing vignette rather than a proper story arc.
     That is not to say that the film is simply a melodrama. Bullet in the Head is filled with magnificent action set pieces (nightclub shootout) and wonderful David Lean-like sequences involving large crowds of people (riots scenes the evoking Tiananmen Square incident or Vietnam exodus scene). However, the real show stealer is the final battle sequence involving the characters played by Tony Leung and Waise Lee.
     Similarly to medieval knights battling on horses, we see the two characters ramming each other with cars. Ultimately, Paul transforms into a Shakespearean lunatic (like Macbeth or Hamlet) as he starts talking to Frank’s skull. It is at this moment when Ben is able to avenge his friend by putting a bullet in Paul’s head. The order has been restored once again, and Ben (in contrast to previous protagonists) did not have to atone for his sins. He already went to hell and back again. At the very end, we see him screaming in despair and throwing away his gun…
     The year 1991 saw the release of Once a Thief which appears to be a complete contradiction of John Woo’s already established template of storytelling. In this instance, we follow three orphaned siblings (Chow Yun-fat, Leslie Cheung, and Cherie Chung) performing heist jobs for their mentor figure (Kenneth Tsang). The movie feels like a side-project for Woo, something tonally lighter with an amazing ensemble cast. It does not function well as a bromance picture at all.
     However, there came Hard Boiled in 1992, the very last picture Woo made before his departure to Hollywood. Without a doubt, Hard Boiled is a classic picture and a landmark of action cinema, praised by the critics and film scholars, which still looks impressive today. Nevertheless, I disagree with the claims that this film is Woo’s finest directorial achievement. Naturally, it cemented his reputation as the master of action genre and it also allowed him to break away from the label of a guy who can only make gangster epics, as this film definitely glamorises the police. Still again, apart from mind-blowing stunts, great performances, and jazz music score, Hard Boiled suffers greatly in terms of a screenplay.
     Police officer “Tequila” Yuen (Chow Yun-fat) tries to eradicate the gun smuggling business which is being controlled by rival triad syndicates. However, this results in a brutal war between the police and the triads. In the meantime, Superintendent Pang (Philip Chan) has placed his own trusted man, Tony (Tony Leung Chiu-Wai), as an undercover cop in one of the syndicates. Tequila is not aware of this and he quickly escalates the situation with one of the triad bosses, Wong (Anthony Wong Chau-sang), while relying on info from his own informant in the syndicate. Soon after, Tequila crosses paths with Tony and learns about his true identity. The two cops discover that Wong has a huge weapons warehouse beneath Maple Group Hospital. They step into action, but the psychotic gangster does not let himself get busted that easily as he takes all patients hostage at the hospital.
     Believe me, there are lots of plot holes and downright illogical behaviour of the characters in this movie, but the general bromance premise is still preserved. Tequila and Tony join forces in order to take down a (yet another) archetypal villain. The female figure played by Teresa Mo is unimportant in the face of spectacular shootouts performed by Tequila and Tony. These protagonists receive perhaps the best ending out of all the heroes of Woo’s movies: After defeating the villain, Tequila remains a police officer and Tony stops being a mole in the triads.
     Allegedly, John Woo and his team had many difficulties with developing the film (for example, the original plot about Tony Leung poisoning children was dropped). Then, the screenwriter Barry Wong passed away halfway through the rewrites and the teahouse raid was filmed without any script whatsoever.
     Consequently, I do not regard Hard Boiled as John Woo’s “all time best of the best”. This status rightfully belongs to Bullet in the Head. However, Hard Boiled is still a wonderful fun as well as a great lesson in filmmaking. In a way, this film is Woo’s love letter to chivalric/bromance cinema. In a commentary for The Killer, the director stated that the righteous characters played by Chow Yun-fat are an expression of his own personality. Whenever we see Chow on the screen, Woo is there too. In Hard Boiled, we get the culmination of this concept as Chow Yun-fat and John Woo share the screen together for the first and only time (Woo’s plays a cameo role of Tequila’s friend in a bar).
     All things considered, John Woo’s movies should not be categorised exclusively as loud and flashy flicks made only for people suffering from empathy deficiency. On the contrary, these are modern morality tales, tragic visual poems which reinvent and reiterate universal values about men of justice putting things right. This is a true bromance at its finest.
     This was my brief trip across John Woo’s movies. Do you have your own favourite bromance flick? Please let me know your thoughts in the comments and thank you for reading.
References: John Woo The Films (Second Edition) by Kenneth E. Hall * John Woo’s A Better Tomorrow by Karen Fang * John Woo’s Bullet in the Head by Tony Williams * John Woo’s The Killer by Kenneth E. Hall.
«Enjoyed this post? Never miss out on future posts by following us» 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comment moderation is switched on due to recent spam postings.